Proposed Cape Cod machine gun range draws fire

Jun 16, 2023

The Download

By CommonWealth Staff 0 Comments May 25, 2023

Cape Cod may be known for ocean breezes, waterbirds, and maybe some raucous seaside vacationers rolling through. But along one stretch, that could include the sound of more than a million bullets fired each year.

A years-long dust-up between Cape residents, local government officials, environmental advocacy groups, and the Massachusetts Army National Guard spun into a new chapter this spring. The US Environmental Protection Agency released a draft determination concluding a proposed $11 million multi-purpose machine gun range at the Joint Base Cape Cod in Bourne could pose a "significant public health hazard" by contaminating the Cape's sole source aquifer.

At a public hearing in Sandwich on Wednesday night, residents cited the EPA report in urging that plans for the machine gun range be scrapped.

Military officials want to clear cut about 170.5 acres of forested land, expanding an existing range on the base that hasn't been in use for about 25 years. The military says their switch from lead to copper bullets, along with regular well monitoring and soil sampling on-site, ensures that there is no risk of water source contamination.

But the EPA, after 20 months of evaluating the proposal, concluded in its draft report that the construction, operation, maintenance, and use of the machine gun range have the potential to contaminate the aquifer that supplies more than 50 percent of the drinking water for the nearby region of Cape Cod.

"The EPA's view is a preventative approach is reasonable and warranted because of decades of environmental impacts that have already damaged the Cape Cod aquifer," said Jane Downing, drinking water branch chief for the region.

Public comments on the proposal will be accepted through June 26, after which the agency will begin finalizing recommendations. If the proposal is still considered a threat to the aquifer, said Downing, "then there’ll be no commitment of federal funds that will be allowed."

The back-and-forth has turned into an awkward referendum on supporting the military and supporting the already vulnerable water source. Though most who testified at the evening meeting objected strongly to the project, a handful said uncertainty is not a good enough reason to stand in the way of military readiness.

"If these troops need the machine gun range, so that they can be trained so they can be competent to serve our country and to serve the taxpayers, then I say give it to them," said one man who only identified himself as Andrew O. and scoffed at potential climate implications.

Many residents in Bourne and nearby Cape towns have balked at the proposal since the initial pitch.

Sandra Faiman-Silva, a Falmouth resident and anthropology professor at Bridgewater State University, said "the current debate over siting of the machine gun rage is a case of those who ignore the past are doomed to repeat it." For decades, the base caused contamination to the Cape's drinking water, leading to more than a billion in investigation and cleanup costs, she noted.

Faiman-Silva and others who testified say it may be too late on that front. "I think you already have and maybe you should just stop and take the advice of the EPA experts," she said.

JENNIFER SMITH

FROM COMMONWEALTH

Big step forward: Tower components for Vineyard Wind, the nation's first industrial-scale wind farm, sail into New Bedford Harbor. The wind farm is expected to start generating some electricity later this year and be fully completed next year. Read more.

Redacted audits: State Auditor Diana DiZoglio defends the decision to redact large chunks of several recent audits because the redacted material could be used to compromise cyber-security at the audited agencies. The ACLU of Massachusetts is suing for release of the entire audits, but the state supervisor of public records said DiZoglio handled the information properly. Read more.

OPINION

Facial recognition software: Sens. Lydia Edwards, Adam Gomez, and Liz Miranda say lawmakers should pass new rules covering the use of facial recognition technology that were developed by a commission of stakeholders. Read more.

FROM AROUND THE WEB

BEACON HILL

The Senate budget will retain a provision to allow some undocumented immigrants to pay in-state tuition rates at public higher education campuses, rejecting an amendment by Republican Sen. Ryan Fattman to remove the budget rider. (Boston Herald)

A new report urges the Legislature to pump $250 million into a rent assistance program that helped stave off evictions during the pandemic thanks to a big infusion of federal funding that is now running dry. (Boston Globe)

MUNICIPAL MATTERS

A project coordinator for a municipal task force on reparations for Black residents was arrested late one night last week in Boston City Hall on trespassing charges and has been fired, city officials say. (Boston Herald)

Worcester city councilors are asking for more information after a new study cast doubt on the financing and impact of Polar Park. CommonWealth earlier this month reported on the study, which estimates Polar Park will cost the city $40 to $60 million over 30 years. (Worcester Telegram)

HEALTH/HEALTH CARE

A Boston research team says a daily multivitamin may help stave off memory loss. (Boston Globe)

WASHINGTON/NATIONAL/INTERNATIONAL

Rep. Jim McGovern is pushing hard to keep work requirements for recipients of federal food assistance out of any debt limit deal reached between President Biden and House Speaker Kevin McCarthy. (Boston Globe)

ELECTIONS

Ron DeSantis's presidential campaign kickoff, which he hoped would position him as the top rival to Donald Trump for the GOP nomination, is instead getting mocked for the technical glitches that marred his effort to make the announcement on Twitter Spaces alongside Elon Musk. (Washington Post)

The Boston City Council approves a new redistricting map to replace the one tossed by a federal judge. (WBUR)

BUSINESS/ECONOMY

Citizens Bank agreed to pay a $9 million civil fine to settle allegations that it violated consumer protection laws in its dealings with some credit card customers. (Boston Globe)

Citing an untenable financial situation, Safe Passage of Northampton announced that it has closed its 45-year-old emergency shelter program for survivors of domestic violence. (MassLive)

EDUCATION

The Boston School Committee approved two elementary school merger plans amid declining district enrollment. (Boston Globe)

ARTS/CULTURE

A report from the Anti-Defamation League says incidents of hate are on the rise in Massachusetts. (GBH)

ENERGY/ENVIRONMENT

WBUR reports on a quarter-acre "food forest" developed on an abandoned lot in the Mattapan section of Boston.

CRIMINAL JUSTICE/COURTS

A corrections officer at the Souza-Baranowski Correctional Center was stabbed on Monday while trying to break up an inmate fight. Union reps say the incident was caused in part because of criminal justice reforms that prioritize inmates over correctional officers. (WBUR)

MEDIA